Well, it’s time for another review of another volume of Dorothy Richardson’s “Pilgrimage” series. I’ve been reading these for almost a year now, and although we’ve all ended up reading different volumes at the same time, it’s been a real pleasure to read these alongside my fellow book bloggers and Virago fans as we’ve gone along (it would be lovely if everyone could comment with where they’re up to and a link to their most recent review). I can’t believe I’ve only got 105 pages to go now!
Dorothy Richardson – “Dimple Hill”
(28 March 2015)
With one book to go in the series, why do I think this is like my experience of the film “Magnolia”, where I was sure everything was going to tie up together at the end … and then it didn’t?
We open on holiday with Florence and Grace in a cathedral town as part of our heroine Miriam’s six-month rest cure – but who are Florence and Grace? I really cannot recall if we’ve met them before. Maybe that little book I bought in Buxton will explain all. There’s some griping about holidaying with friends and not all wanting to do the same thing, and a changed experience in a church, where Miriam describes that she, “felt nothing of her old desire to smash their complacency”, perhaps a sign that she’s maturing (this is handy, as she’s going to be spending quite a while in places of worship quite soon).
Having caught up with Amabel and Michael’s budding romance via a packet of letters that’s been around pillar and post trying to catch up with her (this almost normal novelistic device stood out for me as the rest of the work is so decidedly and carefully against narrative conventions), Miriam goes off to stay with the Roscorlas, a Quaker family, farming in Sussex, who rent out a room. She falls for their simple ways, although she does seem to spend her time at Meeting looking at men and at people’s hats, and while there are some lovely descriptions of the house and the nature surrounding it, she seems to get into one of her interminable misunderstandings over men, upsetting someone’s girl and somehow simultaneously humble-bragging as not presenting as a standard simpering female and fancying (?) herself romantically linked to the man of the house.
It’s all very confusing and seems to end in upset and a hurrying moving on, as ever. Meanwhile, Amabel the fearless fighter for women’s rights has basically got herself in a position where she needs one man (Michael) to rescue her from oppression by another (her brother), which doesn’t seem that ideal.
Bitchy about other young women and their accents, mean about a mother who’s protective of her son, always getting into emotional tangles and being obsessed with men and switching between the first and third person – yes, I know the last point is a feature of the writer, not the character, but they are so closely identified and unfortunately, while I certainly do not have to like and admire every character in a book to enjoy the book, it’s pretty heavy-going when the central character is fundamentally unlikeable and unattractive, as far as I’m concerned. Maybe that’s the point, though. Who knows?
—
Well, that one’s done and just the last, very short, volume and then the small book about Richardson that I picked up and hope to be the Key To All Mysteries to go.
I’m currently reading “Yeah Yeah Yeah”, which is Bob Stanley’s excellent history of pop music from the advent of the vinyl pop single to its demise. Very, very good so far. And I might have bought Greg Rutherford’s autobiography For No Reason. Just because I clicked.
kaggsysbookishramblings
Nov 14, 2016 @ 21:24:12
You *are* doing well – I will catch up eventually, even if I drift into 2017….
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Nov 14, 2016 @ 21:30:41
I couldn’t have done it without knowing everyone else was doing it!
LikeLiked by 1 person
heavenali
Nov 14, 2016 @ 21:31:20
Well done. Just one short book to go. I am sure I will read them one day too. They sound slightly hard work though.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Nov 14, 2016 @ 21:33:31
I wonder if they’d do better being read continuously rather than with so many other books between them, but I’m not sure. I’ll pass them to you soon so they can tempt you! It’s a good series to have read, I understand modernism and reactions to it a lot better, and she’s fascinating to compare to Woolf, too.
LikeLike
heavenali
Nov 14, 2016 @ 21:35:59
I don’t really want them yet _ i have no room on the shelves they will just panic me. I might do them the year after next. I need to make serious in-roads into my tbr – and buy fewer books.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Nov 14, 2016 @ 21:42:27
I’m not sure how long I can hang onto them as am having storage issues, too. I wonder if there’s someone who wants to read then next year who could have them in the meantime.
LikeLiked by 1 person
heavenali
Nov 14, 2016 @ 21:43:47
If you need to get rid that’s fine. You know how good I am at acquiring books when I need them.
LikeLike
Jane @ Beyond Eden Rock
Nov 14, 2016 @ 22:59:13
I think Florence and Grace are the Brooms, who Miriam met back in book two and visited for Christmas a few books later. I’m still a book behind and must congratulate you on keeping going and being so close to the end.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Nov 15, 2016 @ 07:51:05
Oh, that’s amazing remembering, well done! That does sound familiar. And plausible, although you never know with Our Mira, do you! And thank you, it feels good to have almost achieved the whole set. I think I’ll have to start the final one on 1 Dec!
LikeLike
Sarah
Nov 15, 2016 @ 04:18:22
Wow, you’re almost there – well done! I’m feeling reinvigorated by Miriam’s recent vacation in ‘Oberland’, and am now halfway through ‘Dawn’s Left Hand’, so I’ve three and a half books left to go. I’m glad you get confused by the sudden inclusion of characters, too – I thought it was just me! 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Nov 15, 2016 @ 07:51:56
I think I’ve mentioned that before, definitely in my last review, where I mulled over how other writers seem to be able to help us catch up the threads. You have to admire her for being so uncompromising, I think. You’re doing well, too, not so far to go now!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ellie Epp
Dec 07, 2016 @ 03:45:44
surely life is too short for slogging through unwanted books like a good girl trained always to clean her plate
LikeLike
Liz Dexter
Dec 07, 2016 @ 05:57:26
Yes, that’s true, and I do give up on quite a lot of books if I am not enjoying them. My round-up post having finished the series might throw more light on why I persisted with these quite difficult books https://librofulltime.wordpress.com/2016/12/06/book-review-march-moonlight-virago-and-a-competition/ – there was a reward in having read a modernist text that puts others into their context and perspective. It’s certainly made me appreciate Virginia Woolf more!
LikeLike