Gosh, that’s a long title isn’t it! Two old favourites and multiple re-reads to review today, one of which was for Kaggsy and Simon‘s 1977 club and the other of which is an appropriate title for the month it’s read in, quite by accident (they’re small books, so shorter reviews), an epic fail on a re-read (I was warned! Kaggsy in fact warned me!) and a super acquisition from a lovely friend.
Let’s get going, then …
Georgette Heyer – “April Lady”
(03 June 2017 – Oxfam books)
From 1957, this is slightly later period Heyer, which surprised me when I read it, as there’s such a slew of cant and argot and jargon that slightly obfuscated the plot that I thought it was a less mature one.
It’s also interesting in that I think it might be the only (if not, it’s one of a very few) of her novels where the hero and heroine are already married at the start of the action. However, although they both married for love, Lady Nell Cardross believes her Earl married her for convenience, and still has Another, and the Earl believes she married him for his money. All very sortable-outable were it not for their respective brother and half-sister, both pretty silly, who get Nell involved in all sorts of plots and businesses, so there’s not time or bandwith to manage it. A very short but enjoyable read with all the London atmosphere and detail you’d want and an interesting ending. Although she’s slight, she writes well and I always recommend a Heyer for a comfort read.
Diana Wynne Jones – “Charmed Life”
(1980s – soon to be replaced. An Unfortunate Incident with a long-gone cat in the 1990s which I thought had been cleaned up has left a lasting stain (no odour) on a few of my children’s books, which I’m going to have to spend vast amounts of time and money tracking down and rebuying. So be it!)
This book was published in 1977 and represents my contribution to the 1977 Club (unfortunately, Bruce Chatwin’s “In Patagonia”, which I also have, was too substantial to fit into a very busy reading week, and see below for the other candidate).
A boy who is an orphan and doesn’t think very much of himself, overshadowed by his remaining family and domineering ward, finds out he has something to do with magic. There’s a powerful enchanter whose name must NOT be mentioned, a turrety castle with magical shape-shifting grounds and all sorts of spells designed to annoy other youngsters. Hmm … yet written in 1977, you say?
I’ve spent a lot of time and energy trying to persuade Harry Potter fans to embrace the (in my eyes) superior Diana Wynne Jones books. Her Chronicles of Chrestomanci are well written, funny, engaging and short! This one was a re-read and I hadn’t read it for ages. I remembered some details, like the magic book of matches that has something to do with our hero, Eric “Cat” Chant and the violin that’s turned into a cat, but had completely forgotten the brilliant Janet Chant, brought in effectively from our world as a rapid replacement at a pivotal moment, more used to wearing trousers than Cat’s original sister’s fancy Edwardian style clothes and very down to earth. Love her!
One interesting feature I had forgotten is the magic garden which allows people to slip through into different worlds – this contains things from “the dawn of all the words” and includes a magic doorway which is like a rough stone lintel – reminding anyone of bits from C.S. Lewis’s “The Magician’s Nephew” and “The Last Battle”?
A DNF
I had originally picked Angela Carter’s “The Passion of New Eve” to re-read for the 1977 Club. I loved it (I thought). I’d read it a few times in my younger, brand-new-feminist years and loved the themes of gender identity and gender reassignment. Then I saw Kaggsy hadn’t been keen and asked why. “The unremitting rapes”. Oh, right. Well, I didn’t even get to the unremitting rapes; I gave up in the sado-masochistic manky rat-infested flat in post-apocalyptic New York. I hated the way black people were portrayed, I wasn’t keen on the wish-fulfilment acts of violent Women roaming the streets, and it was just pretty horrible. Sorry, Angela Carter, I’m going to leave you there.
A lovely book confession
I’m still not entirely sure how this happened, but my lovely friend Cari got hold of a print and e copy of this book by the amazing runner, Deena Kastor, and then happened upon her at a race expo in Washington DC and a book event in New York, and somehow she has ended up with a copy she’s read and a signed bookplate to keep and I’ve ended up with the hard copy book signed to me by Deena! Thank you so much Cari! I’ve just discovered Wendy from Taking the Long Way Home’s Book Club and this is her April book, so I’m hoping to fit it in after this weekend (I do have that Readathon I’m doing the last weekend in the month but I fear that’s going to be a Tardis of books shoehorned into not enough time!) and I’ve also requested her May book via NetGalley.
Phew, that’s a lot of stuff, hope you’re still with me! I’m currently reading Christopher Booker’s “The Seven Basic Plots” (which is going to take me some time) and “The Lido” by Libby Page, which comes out today and has had a lot of chatter and which is ABSOLUTELY LOVELY so far (I sat down to read it at breakfast and tore myself away at 33%) – it’s the story of two women who have got a bit lost in life battling to save a Lido, and is set in Brixton and Brockwell, beautifully realised). I really hope it lives up to this first third. I also need to start “Running the Smoke” which is 26 tales of running the London Marathon, a must-read as I go down to spectate for the first time in years, and support my lovely friend Bernice, running her first marathon.
What are you reading? Have you had a booky pinch point this year yet where there are just TOO MANY BOOKS to read in one week?
Apr 19, 2018 @ 08:44:59
I’ve never though much of HP — I read 1.5 of the books when I was 22; I’m sure I missed my moment — but Wynne Jones sounds appealing. Worth an adult reading? And if so, which one should I pick up first?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Apr 19, 2018 @ 08:53:22
Definitely worth reading – plenty for an adult to enjoy. She’s a much better writer than J K Rowling.
LikeLike
Apr 19, 2018 @ 08:54:43
Charmed Life is a great place to start – that was my first DWJ and my son’s. My other son started with The Ogre Downstairs.
LikeLike
Apr 19, 2018 @ 09:09:23
I read them all including buying no 5 within 24 hours of it publishing (caught up in peer group pressure) but always read them thinking she’s not as good as DWG. As Luci sensibly says, I would start with the Chronicles of Chrestomanci, but also The Ogre Downstairs is simply wonderful. Like E. Nesbit for the late 20th century in many ways.
LikeLike
Apr 19, 2018 @ 08:51:52
I love Charmed Life and Diana Wynne Jones. Danny has read all the Chrestomanci books (7 of them) but sadly the set I bought him from the BookPeople is no longer on offer. Conor is now reading Charmed Life and enjoying it too, though unlike D he hasn’t previously read Harry Potter. If we ever get to organise another meet up or if you’re doing a trip to Persephone, I think I can give you one of my copies as Danny has the set and I have it on my Kindle.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Apr 19, 2018 @ 09:09:59
I was thinking we should organise another meetup! Unfortunately I’ve just placed an order for a second hand copy before seeing this, but thank you!
LikeLike
Apr 19, 2018 @ 12:36:13
I’m *sooooo* glad it was not just me with the Carter. It was just so horrible and bleak and I couldn’t find anything to redeem it!
As for DWJ, I agree with you and Luci so much on this. She’s a much better writer than JKR, and in my 20s my BFF and I were obsessed with her books – Fire and Hemlock was a favourite. We were lucky enough to meet her at an event once, and she was absolutely lovely. Everyone should read her….
LikeLiked by 1 person
Apr 19, 2018 @ 13:56:07
And I’m glad it wasn’t just me. I must have been made of much stronger stuff – or not seen so much of the world – when I read and loved it. I did also have the feeling of having read that bio of her and some of her time in Japan perhaps creeping into it which also creeped me out (is that the book I was going to pass you, I wonder?). And hooray for DWJ indeed!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Apr 19, 2018 @ 14:01:25
It might well be! I have loved Carter’s writing in the past, and I’ll give her another chance. However, I was chatting with Eldest Child about it last night, and he did The Magic Toyshop at uni and said it was a bit rapey too which he really didn’t like. Most odd….
LikeLiked by 1 person
Apr 19, 2018 @ 14:05:51
I certainly couldn’t read The Bloody Chamber again! I did enjoy Nights at the Circus when I reread it fairly recently. Oh dear!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Apr 19, 2018 @ 13:07:14
Oh gosh, that is NOT what I thought the Carter would be about! I’m mentally moving it off my tbr pile…
LikeLiked by 1 person
Apr 19, 2018 @ 13:56:52
I’m wondering what you thought it would be but you would NOT like it. Put it aside at once! Pass it on to someone else! Step awaaaaay from the Carter!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Apr 20, 2018 @ 12:28:34
I’ve only read Wise Children, so I guess I was expecting something funny, whimsical, and a bit naughty, but not… well, not this!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Apr 23, 2018 @ 09:19:12
Lack of whimsy is evident!
LikeLike
Apr 19, 2018 @ 16:23:16
Yep! That’s pretty much how it happened. She didn’t have books available at the Cherry Blossom Expo because it was ahead of the publication date but she didn’t want us to walk away empty handed, hence the book plate. The hard copy came with the event registration, which Road Runners/Shape Magazine were holding ahead of the Women’s Half Marathon this past Sunday. I wasn’t running it, but the event was open to public. That the hard copy from an independent bookstore (the bookmark I left in there for you as a touch of New York) came with a free digital download was a nice surprise. Yay publisher.
Wendy’s bookclub is amazing & evil in the same way Runners’ Bookshelf is. We love it, Mt. TBR groans 😀 Her running blog is also a really good read.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Apr 19, 2018 @ 21:04:15
All makes sense all put together like that. Can’t wait to read it! I have subscribed to her running blog, too, as it seems really good. Fortunately I have April’s book obvs, have requested May’s on NetGalley (WHOSE fault???) and have read June’s, so all good, honest!
LikeLike
Apr 20, 2018 @ 13:38:08
¯\_(ツ)_/¯. No idea whatsoever where you might have heard May’s was available. But all’s fair — I just started to read Running the Smoke. I’m pretty sure if we tallied all the books over the years we’re 50 / 50 — and have read so many new to us books in the process 😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
Apr 20, 2018 @ 13:41:23
Yeah, I think that’s true! I started reading Running the Smoke at lunch but have only just started the first story. I want to have enough of it to read on the way down and back up to / from London at the weekend. Lending it to my friend who’s running London AFTER she’s finished running it!
LikeLike
Apr 20, 2018 @ 14:08:31
I just finished the intro but already like the premise. have a 12m commute but hope to find some weekend reading time
LikeLiked by 1 person
Apr 19, 2018 @ 17:56:40
I’ve not found A carter always to my taste; some of Bloody Chamber is ok (it was an A level set text I taught years ago), but Nights at the Circus left me cold. I’ve dipped into the C Brooker but don’t much care for those Archetypal Story books – too reductive – but some useful insights e emerge
LikeLiked by 1 person
Apr 19, 2018 @ 21:05:28
I liked Circus but I am drawing a line now. What a shame, but she feels almost dated in her language, which seems weird to me now. I feel the Brooker may become reductive – he’s certainly pushing that he’s the only person to have found this stuff. It’s a LARGE book, isn’t it, so we shall see!
LikeLike
Apr 19, 2018 @ 20:21:54
April Lady isn’t one of my favourite Heyers, but I did enjoy it. Her books are perfect when you’re looking for something fun and undemanding but still well written. The Passion of New Eve sounds awful, though. I’m pleased I didn’t decide to read that one for 1977 Club!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Apr 19, 2018 @ 21:06:28
Yes, indeed. I enjoyed the slightly different viewpoint in there being a married couple at the heart of it, and there was no chase sequence for once! I think people had a lucky escape from the Carter. I do think one other person was planning to read it, so hopefully they got something out of it!
LikeLike
Apr 19, 2018 @ 20:57:51
I never read HP and hadn’t heard of Charmed before. Sorry about cat related book staining incident.
I am now very glad I didn’t buy a copy of The Passion of New Eve – it sounds nasty.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Apr 19, 2018 @ 21:02:40
I ended up going through them ALL and there were only five damaged (I think I must have thrown others out at the time) so it was under £20 to replace the lot on ABE.And yes a lucky escape – feminist classic, not so much, it turned out. Ew.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Apr 19, 2018 @ 20:59:55
Golly Georgette Heyer, now that’s a name from my past. Though I never got on with her to the same extent as I did with Jean Plaidy….
I really should try Diana Wynne Jones given her Welsh origin
LikeLiked by 1 person
Apr 19, 2018 @ 21:03:11
I ran through all of Plaidy but only once, Heyer has been a constant since then! DWJ is excellent and very rewarding!
LikeLike
Apr 22, 2018 @ 15:08:01
There was another one around the time of Plaidy but I can’t recall the author’s name now unfortunately.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Apr 23, 2018 @ 09:26:53
Victoria Holt and Philippa Carr? (All the same person along with Plaidy!! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eleanor_Hibbert )
LikeLike
Apr 25, 2018 @ 20:19:46
Ah yes those are the ones I was thinking of
LikeLiked by 1 person
Apr 19, 2018 @ 22:10:36
Fortunately Angela Carter has never appealed to me, so now I have a great reason for never succumbing! I’m always willing to succumb to Ms Heyer though…
LikeLiked by 1 person
Apr 20, 2018 @ 07:15:54
Always happy to sink into a Heyer. I have no new ones left (well, “new”) on the TBR but have kept them to re-read.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Apr 19, 2018 @ 22:56:55
I’m so glad an early Diana Wynne Jones made it into this week – the more exposure for her the better. I just reread Deep Secret and The Merlin Conspiracy for March Magics (hosted each year at We Be Reading, if you’d like to connect with more fans).
LikeLiked by 1 person
Apr 20, 2018 @ 07:16:30
Oh brilliant ones to read. I love all of hers though this is a favourite – I was so chuffed to see her on the books published in 1977 list!
LikeLiked by 1 person
The 1977 Club starts today! – Stuck in a Book
Apr 20, 2018 @ 12:12:45
Apr 22, 2018 @ 22:17:26
I’m so interested to read your review of ‘Charmed Life’. Somehow, I’ve never read any Diana Wynne Jones (I know!) and I’m currently on the hunt for recommendations. Is this a good place to start? Or perhaps something else? Would welcome any tips. I’ve long suspected I’d enjoy reading her and your review has confirmed that for me. I tackled the Chatwin and had to confess in my review that I hadn’t quite finished it when it came time to write it up before the end of the week!
LikeLike
Apr 23, 2018 @ 09:28:31
Hello Faye and welcome to the blog. I do recommend this one or The Ogre Downstairs as good places to start with DWJ. This starts a great series. She’s such a good author.
I haven’t followed up all of Simon’s list yet, I can imagine the Chatwin was a bit of a chewy one so not surprised it spilled over! Glad someone tackled him, though.
LikeLike
Book review – Deena Kastor – “Let Your Mind Run” #amreading | Adventures in reading, writing and working from home
Apr 30, 2018 @ 14:20:10
May 02, 2018 @ 16:24:25
I have been meaning to read Georgette Heyer for a while now. I keep running across her books at the library and thinking “not yet, but soon!”. I also saw a biography about her which I sat right down and flipped through (even though I was supposed to be working at the time) – she sounds worth reading about. Have you read the biography?
LikeLiked by 1 person
May 03, 2018 @ 07:11:13
I’ve read a biography a while ago but really I just love reading the books. Go for Sylvester, The Grand Sophy or Bath Tangle if you can find them. They’re quick reads, so I say go for it!
LikeLiked by 1 person
May 03, 2018 @ 16:44:01
Thanks for the suggestions!
LikeLiked by 1 person
May 12, 2018 @ 05:28:03
Am a GH fan, but didn’t know about Diana Jones. Sounds fascinating. Will try to get hold of one
LikeLike
May 12, 2018 @ 05:39:12
Always glad to find other GH fans! I’m not sure she goes together perfectly with DWJ, not sure what the fan overlap is, but Jones is very good, highly recommended. Do pop back if you read any and let me know your thoughts!
LikeLike