It’s book review central here as I carve out more reading time and get to grips with my 20 books of summer and review books. How lucky I am to have such a wide variety to read!
First off, I need to report on one extra book I read in July – Stephen Rutt’s “The Seafarers”, which I’ve reviewed for Shiny New Books. This was a wonderful book about the (oddly hard to define) seabirds of Britain, taking in locations from the Shetlands in the North to the Scillies in the South, with beautiful, artistically written descriptions of land, sea and bird life. Although this has been talked about as being about the help nature can give to mental health, this isn’t a huge part of the story – while I know some readers like a lot of memoir in their nature writing, I like a book to be about the nature and the person’s reaction to that.
I also liked the respect the author paid to previous nature writers who have gone before him, bringing back memories of those older volumes sitting in bird hides and the hotels you stay in on birding trips. Altogether a lovely book and highly recommended. You can read my full review here and I know the lovely editors at Shiny will appreciate you popping over and having a read (you can follow their Facebook and Twitter accounts, too).
Now for #20 books of summer, another slimmer volume in the All Virago (and Persephone) All August part of the project.Ā Kaggsy from the Ramblings sent me this one in November via Heaven-Ali, just like “The Eye of Love” (except I’m afraid I’ll probably be putting “Maurice Guest” to one side as it looks a bit turgid and Germaine Greer thinks it’s not as good as this one. Do I do everything Greer says? No: for a start, I am still fully underclothed at all times, however much I read “The Female Eunuch” as a teenager. Anyway, this was an interesting read, especially for its Australian setting.
Henry Handel Richardson – “The Getting of Wisdom”
30 November 2018 – from Kaggsy
The getting of wisdom is of course nothing to do with the rote-learning at the boarding school where this book is set: it’s all about how to get on with people, something our heroine never quite grasps. Like “The Eye of Love” this is another book about convention: however, here, convention stifles and squashes Laura Rambotham’s spirit and natural ebulliance, making her by turns over shy but over confident, mendacious, smarmy and over religious as she works her way unsuccessfully through a couple of years of boarding school. Her mother classifies her as disobedient and self-willed and she heart-breakingly never works out how to get on with people, missing the point generally all the way along, although a hint of her future near the end suggests that she might get what she wants eventually, unlike her friends.
We feel for Laura’s poor mother, keen on needlework but mocked for her garish designs, and having to support herself and her family, eschewing stays but trying to keep everyone on the straight and narrow. There’s a great feeling for a veneer of imposed and strict ‘culture’ over the chaos of life in Australia, and the backdrop means Laura gets to rest from school by the thundering ocean, not something that features much in British school stories except as a source of danger for rescues!
There are some good, sharp comments about how to write, and how writing allows to lie as if something was true, much easier than keeping things straight in life. There’s not a huge amount of plot but as Greer says in the introduction, it’s about someone who is “ordinary, and therefore deeply important”.
This was Book 9 in my 20 Books of Summer project.
Still reading “Spam Tomorrow” (not Jam, which I claimed yesterday!) by Verily Anderson; still enjoying it very much. How are your 20 books going??
Aug 08, 2019 @ 11:14:09
Happy to be a book enabler… š I remember being very interested in the culture and setting of this one, not so worried about lack of plot. Maurice Guest *does* look a bit chunky…
LikeLiked by 1 person
Aug 08, 2019 @ 11:15:45
Yes, the Australian setting for a fairly typical school story was fascinating. I had a flick through MG and it’s been put aside but you’re 2:1 up on massive successes and I still have “Clash”!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Aug 08, 2019 @ 11:41:32
Ah, I’m looking forward to seeing what you think of it! š
LikeLiked by 1 person
Aug 08, 2019 @ 11:21:37
I agree the Rutt was a lovely book. I had a proof copy and corrected all the tense slippages in pencil, assuming they were in error. Did you have a finished copy? (Now I’m curious to know which birds you’ve seen that your husband hasn’t. I’ve nearly but not quite been dive-bombed by bonxies on Shetland; we carried big sticks!)
LikeLiked by 1 person
Aug 08, 2019 @ 11:30:01
Oh, that’s interesting. It was odd reading but, like I said in the Shiny review, reminded me of the sagas. I did have a finished copy.
And I’ve seen a bittern in the 1990s and he’s been to lots of bitterny places and has never heard a boom; and on a birding holiday in France I got fed up of the interminable drive in a car followed by walk in a forest so sat in the car with the doors open, reading my book, while he and the guide went into the forest to look for a black woodpecker. You can guess the rest!
LikeLike
Aug 08, 2019 @ 11:40:04
I usually send E&T a list of corrections so they can get things right in the paperback, but I was late in reading my proof and just assumed they would have tidied it up. As you say, though, perhaps there was a good reason for it!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Aug 08, 2019 @ 11:42:25
He said he was a writer, somewhere in the book, so I was assuming it was done with artistic intent. Could be wrong, though!
LikeLike
Aug 08, 2019 @ 11:43:47
I love The Getting of Wisdom, and it was made into quite a good movie in the 70s when the Australian movie industry was young and vibrant. It is of course very autobiographical and so an important insight into a major author (with just a few hints that Laura (and HHR) might prefer girls to boys).
Maurice Guest is something else, but also based on the authors years studying music in Leipzig. In my opinion it is HHR’s one excursion into modernism as the ‘hero’ makes a meal of winning and hanging onto the girl he loves, but certainly worth the effort.
HHR returned to German music for her last novel, The Young Cosima, which is a fictionalised life of Cosima Wagner, and very well done.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Aug 08, 2019 @ 11:49:45
I was hoping my Australian readers would spot this and comment! I had a flick through MG and the modernism aspect put me off a bit (having waded through Dorothy Richardson’s “Pilgrimage” series a few years ago). This was excellent, though, and very memorable.
LikeLike
Aug 08, 2019 @ 13:10:34
The Seabirds book sounds very nice.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Aug 08, 2019 @ 14:08:05
It’s very good and well done.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Aug 08, 2019 @ 18:06:28
I love the books about the birdlife!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Aug 08, 2019 @ 18:15:46
The Seafarers is lovely, and I have a few more on my To Be Read pile, too!
LikeLike
Aug 09, 2019 @ 13:43:51
The Seafarers does sound lovely, I enjoy some nature writing, but have to confess I do like some memoir slotted in, as long as it doesn’t take over.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Aug 18, 2019 @ 11:24:22
It’s hard to describe – I like having the person in the book but when it’s all about the death of their parent to the detriment of the nature writing, that’s where my line is drawn.
LikeLike
Aug 24, 2019 @ 20:43:02
Great review, Liz. Can recommend the Seabird’s Cry too
LikeLiked by 1 person
Aug 25, 2019 @ 17:03:18
Thank you. Yes, that’s on my radar, too. So many bird books, so little time!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Non-fiction November: week one #NonfictionNovember | Adventures in reading, running and working from home
Nov 02, 2019 @ 07:51:02
State of the TBR January 2020 and reading stats / best books of 2019 | Adventures in reading, running and working from home
Jan 01, 2020 @ 17:30:15