It’s quite a quick review for Assembly here, which I downloaded on 01 April this year. It’s had a lot of buzz about it, and the description of a young Black woman attending a big posh White garden party and deciding she had had Enough appealed to me – in fact it was touted as shocking, which worried me a bit.
I just struggled to get to grips with this. I think I’m not adept enough with literary criticism or getting to grips with the modern novel. It was episodic and full of flashbacks and bits of thoughts. I could compare it to “Open Water” in the sort of floaty and slightly confusing narrative (although it had a more standard first-person narrator). There were flashes of “Queenie” in her workplace life and the micro-aggressions and work best friends but that was way more straightforward to read (and sorry to compare this only to books by other Black authors – looks like those are the group of modern novels I seem to be reading at the moment!).
There are great moments in it, the reader has to work for information a lot of the time and that got me confused, but it does have important things to say about micro- and macroaggressions and how exhausted Black women are by their code-switching, “Work twice as hard” lives (this was a theme in “The Other Black Girl,” of course, too). This, unnamed, heroine takes a different and, yes, I suppose shocking, strategy to give in to the exhaustion. I liked how Brown wove in important information about the British Government’s destruction of records of citizenship which came out in the Windrush Scandal (recently also highlighted in “Burning the Books“), but I’m afraid I couldn’t work out why the narrator was sending off her passport which initiated that discussion.
So for me, good in parts but confusing – but I’m sure a lot of that is down to me and my distance from reading books as critically and academically as this one might need. I’d struggle with the structure whoever the author and whatever the topic. It’s good to have experimental novels by Global Majority People authors getting published and shared on services like NetGalley, of course.
Thank you to Hamish Hamilton for making this book available for me to read via NetGalley in return for an honest review.
Jun 13, 2021 @ 13:08:54
Ohh, this sounds perfect to me: thank you! I’m a lover of the “puzzle novel” on one end of that extreme, and I enjoy the act of assembling a kind of truth from a fragmented narrative along the way to that extreme too.
LikeLike
Jun 13, 2021 @ 15:51:45
Aha, absolutely perfect for you, then – marvellous and I feel I’ve justified taking on a NetGalley copy of it!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Jun 13, 2021 @ 13:42:13
I struggled to connect with this one as well, but also found it far too similar to other books I’ve read — the ones by Black authors that you’ve mentioned, but also a lot of others about young women’s work lives and relationships. And ultimately I didn’t find her decision convincing. BIP (above) will probably enjoy the style more than we did.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Jun 13, 2021 @ 15:52:52
Ah, that’s made me feel loads better about it (also: I didn’t engage with it, rather than it made me feel a bit dim, for the win!). And useful that it’s basically millennial type books rather than books by and about young Black people in particular.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Jun 13, 2021 @ 16:07:37
Thanks for this review as it’s useful for me from a work perspective (in terms of matching readers with books that might interest them). I too have seen quite a lot of publicity for this, much of it very enthusiastic, so it’s good to see a more balanced perspective. Not for me personally, but it may well appeal to some readers who link this kind of style.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Jun 13, 2021 @ 16:09:36
Thank you, that’s lovely to read actually, and yes, it’s a good balance giving a different perspective on the “young people at work and in life” type books that are around at the moment, as Bookish Beck points out usefully above.
LikeLike
Jun 13, 2021 @ 19:40:01
Sounds like this wasn’t one for you, Liz, but not every book is for every reader. If you don’t engage with a book in some way it’s a struggle.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Jun 14, 2021 @ 09:02:47
Yes, indeed, it was a shame as I thought based on the publicity I read about it that I would like it, but I didn’t get out of it what I was supposed to, I feel!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Jun 14, 2021 @ 16:05:09
Oh what a shame, the premise of this sounds really good. But I think after your experience I will steer clear, at least for now.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Jun 14, 2021 @ 18:32:37
You read more modern and more tricky books like all your translated ones so you might get to grips with it better than I did, so I don’t like to put you off entirely!
LikeLike
Feb 14, 2022 @ 12:06:32
Just returning to your review, now that I’ve read the book! Thanks for alerting me to it as it has given me a better understanding of how you (and potentially other readers) have perceived the book. I can see how the vignette style and format might not work for every reader, especially given the starkness of the style and tone.
Maybe I just read the novel at the right time (for me), when I was ready for this kind of book? Timing can be a funny thing…looking back at my previous comment, I didn’t think Assembly was for me at the time. How interesting that is to see, given my response to the book itself!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Feb 15, 2022 @ 06:19:27
Your two comments are interesting, aren’t they – I wonder what made you change your mind (positive reviews from people you trust?). I just found so much of value in it I was disappointed by the muddying of them by the structure and confusing decisions, I think, looking back now, if that makes sense. Also I did read a few books about millennials around the same time, and I am clearly becoming an old codger!
LikeLike
Feb 15, 2022 @ 09:30:23
Yes, it does make sense. It was an accumulation of positive endorsement that made me want to read Assembly. Firstly the Goldsmith shortlisting, then Foyles named it as their Fiction Book of the Year, and finally, its appearance in various ‘Books of the Year’ round-ups, especially those from critics and writers. (I also read Claire Keegan’s Small Things Like These for similar reasons – so many writers had named it as a standout book of the year that it became hard for me to resist!) The Rathbones Folio Prize shortlisting happened after I’d read Assembly (and the Keegan), but it’s another highly respected endorsement.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Feb 15, 2022 @ 09:59:15
I hear you – I am moving towards Small Things Like These for the same reasons!
LikeLike