Hooray, it’s time for Kaggsy and Simon’s twice-yearly Year Book Club, and this week it’s 1976. Warned well in advance, I tackled the 889 pages of Alex Haley’s American Black history saga, “Roots”, as you do. Simon’s post collecting reviews is here and I’m sure there will be loads of great resources to explore as the week continues! I was fortunate enough to be able to read this book through September along with the bloggers Buried in Print (review here) and The Australian Legend (his review here), 30 chapters a week, every week; it was a pleasure and privilege to read it alongside them and also fascinating to get their Canadian and Australian perspectives respectively.
Alex Haley – “Roots”
(18 August 2021)
So Dad has joined the others up there. I feel that they do watch and guide, and I also feel that they join me in the hope that this story of our people can help to alleviate the legacies of the fact that preponderantly the histories have been written by the winners. (p. 888)
I’d known about this seminal saga of Kunta Kinte, his life in Africa, his abduction and Middle Passage on an American slave ship, his slavery, family and descendants seemingly forever, but it seemed to be too big, too brutal, too hard to read. I’m so glad I was prodded into attempting it by the 1976 Club – of course I can’t say I enjoyed it as such, but it was a compelling read, fascinating, human, and I learned a lot.
There was more than I expected about Kunta’s life – over a quarter of the book – and I loved reading about the society in his village in The Gambia, every day life and his growing up. I was particularly engaged by the fact that Haley doesn’t give explanations for a lot of the terms used, for implements, clothing, kinds of food – he just places the terms there and, presumably, expects you to know what they meant or look them up (some I did, some I did, if you see what I mean).
The descriptions of his capture and sale, his attempts to escape and the driving down of his spirit until he lacks the will to try again, are of course devastating. They’re brutal and deeply horrible, as are the rape of Kizzy and other scenes, but not gratuitously so: we needed and need to know this stuff.
As a reading group, we differed a bit on our attitudes to the way history was inserted into the narrative once we were in the US. I accepted the chunks of reported history as I felt it was realistic: house servants picked up scraps of news while serving dinner to their masters; slaves who were drivers or otherwise accompanied their masters out of the house and far away were able to bring back news; news travelled between people almost by osmosis then someone would report it to an audience, and I’m sure that’s what happened. I didn’t find it too didactic or bolted on and it kept the narrative rooted in history.
Bill found a link between the matriarchs of the family while I saw a line of males; Marcie made a great link between the treatment and breeding of the cockfighting birds and that of the slaves (there were too many “chickens” in that part of the book, needed as they were to advance the plot, and I think we all agreed on that!) which I’d not made. Discussing the sections as we went along by email was a great addition to the reading experience personally.
Looking through my post-it note markers, the overriding feeling is of heart-break. Kunta can’t feel he can talk to his mother when he lives in the village, then he’s snatched away and never gets to tell her what she means to him. Kizzy is snatched away and we lose sight of Kunta (of course; we’re seeing this through the family oral history, so when someone moves on, the continuing story of those they were with is lost) and she never sees her parents again. Kunta’s dignity and retention of his Muslim faith are so moving, too. We all know of the inhumanity of slavery of course, but this slams it home.
Maybe surprisingly, there are some beautiful descriptions of landscape and birds, in Africa and America. The landscape is always drawn very clearly, so you can see it in your mind’s eye. This is used to devastating effect in the slave ship and chase scenes, of course, but the occasional beauty and the clear interiors were not something I was expecting.
There’s so much more I can write about – the interrogation of attitudes towards integration: could Black slaves and White owners ever be more than slaves and owners; was it important to retain African bloodlines? – but really I’d say if you can, go and read this important book.
Was Haley writing history or historical fiction? Of course there was a debate about his sources and his researcher integrity. But I don’t think that matters: first off, it’s entirely plausible to have an oral history go that far back in a family, especially when in more recent memory and presumably before the details were chanted to each new family member. I know my gran’s grandfather was Spanish, and have access to his name and town of origin, and presumably my cousins’ children know this, too, so that’s a lot of generations here. And while conversations and details are obviously invented, the whole is plausible and gives an incredibly vivid picture of life for each succeeding generation, the struggles they faced, their psychology and everyday life, and that’s got to be more valuable than quibbling over exact accuracy.
My Vintage edition had an introduction by David Olusoga which sets the book in its own context and was very useful. He points out it was a massive counterpoint to a narrative of the “benign and fatherly slave-owner” (x) which existed at the time and also writes of the effect it had on Black British people, too.
And what did I do just the other day? Take delivery of a copy of “Queen”, Alex Haley and David Stevens’ 915-page (I know) story of Haley’s mother’s family …
In 1976, I was four years old, so I don’t recall the book or series coming out. Reading it now, having David Olusoga, Afua Hirsch, Sathnam Sanghera et. al to tell us about the Middle Passage, colonialism and slavery histories, it felt like I was prepared for what I was going to read, that I had some understanding of the history I was going to encounter, and the cruelty, if not the visceral feelings of what it was like to be an enslaved person. I would be fascinated to hear from anyone who experienced the book or series at the time, how much you already knew on the subject, what it did for you and how it changed you and your attitudes, if you have the energy to tell me.
MarinaSofia
Oct 12, 2021 @ 09:17:47
I do seem to remember watching the TV series at some point, and it having a real impact upon me. But since I see that the TV series came out in 1977, I was probably too small to remember it then, so I must have watched a rerun of it (or else it came quite a bit later to Austrian TV).
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Oct 12, 2021 @ 09:27:34
I think it has had reruns, and also I know at least some school children here were shown it in history lessons in the 90s, too.
LikeLiked by 1 person
wadholloway
Oct 12, 2021 @ 09:40:49
I was started on parenthood (and poverty) when Roots came out and didn’t see it, though I remember the hype surrounding it. I wonder what I believed about American slavery back then. Nothing probably, though I was aware of and a supporter of Black Power through its connection with the anti-Vietnam War movement.
By coincidence there is an excellent essay in today’s Guardian: Built on the Bodies of Slaves, about the roots of European prosperity.
I enjoyed our readalong and particularly spreading it out so that we had progress discussions each week
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Oct 13, 2021 @ 07:31:20
That’s interesting that you had the link to Black Power all the way over in Australia, fascinating. I so enjoyed reading it along with you and Marcie and the different perspectives we all had – and discussing it section by section helped me really think about it, too, a bit like when I read a book slowly with Emma, but less so. I think we all got something out of it, too.
LikeLike
mallikabooks15
Oct 12, 2021 @ 10:05:25
Great review. This is indeed an important read dealing with so many themes from personal to broader ones. A book that I would certainly like to pick up one day when I’m feeling braver.
889 pages is quite something; all my three picks together come to 550 or so (though the Alistair MacLean had really tiny print and seems longer in other editions).
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Oct 13, 2021 @ 07:32:47
I won’t say it was an easy read in terms of the content, but he writes really well and clearly so you just keep on going and it’s OK – and you know I have a low tolerance for unpleasant scenes in books. I suppose because it’s researched reportage rather than gratuitous scenes for the sake of it, it worked better. I hope you do get to read it. And just the one for me, it’s funny to think you and probably others got three in for the same page count!
LikeLike
mallikabooks15
Oct 13, 2021 @ 07:37:49
I might have even fit in a fourth, if I found another slim one and still been under your page count š But I’m glad you did manage to pick it up. I do want to but when I’m more in the mind for it.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Oct 13, 2021 @ 07:38:50
Yes, you need to read it intentionally and with space to do so in your mind and calendar.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Rebecca Foster
Oct 12, 2021 @ 11:25:25
I remember a rerun of the programme being on telly when I was young. Because of the content I probably wouldn’t have been allowed to watch the whole thing, but I remember my parents were engaged. Marcie is a very percipient partner for buddy reads š A novel that your review brings to mind for me is Homegoing by Yaa Gyasi ā I see you have that one on your wish list.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Oct 13, 2021 @ 07:34:45
Yes, I’m more and more inclined to read Homegoing now, two people also mentioned it on the fairly lively discussion that ensued on my Facebook share of this review! Another book that was mentioned by an British in America friend was J. Drew Lanham’s The Home Place, which you may well know about already but might pique your interest as it’s a nature one, too.
LikeLike
Helen
Oct 12, 2021 @ 12:17:32
I read this years ago as a teenager and can’t remember it very well, except that I found the Kunta Kinte section fascinating but started to lose interest after it moved on to Chicken George and the later generations. I was probably too young to really appreciate everything the book had to say about slavery, so maybe I should read it again one day.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Oct 13, 2021 @ 07:35:52
I’m impressed by the people I’m encountering who read it as a teenager. But I can confirm that the Chicken George bits were pretty tedious (though Marcie’s perception on that did help after the fact); it picked up again with Tom and the journey to a new town after Emancipation, though.
LikeLike
kaggsysbookishramblings
Oct 12, 2021 @ 13:20:42
What a fascinating review and a fascinating choice for 1976 Liz – well done for committing to this! I’m ancient enough to remember the show being on TV and it having a massive impact, although I never read the book. So useful to have an edition with all that supporting material to help put the book in context. I think it was obviously really important at the time.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Oct 13, 2021 @ 07:36:46
Yes, I hadn’t quite gathered its importance in the UK, too, but that came through in Olusoga’s introduction. Such an important read and I’m so glad your 1976 Club inspired me to read it!
LikeLiked by 1 person
hopewellslibraryoflife
Oct 12, 2021 @ 14:21:26
Very good review. I was 14 when this came out and I remember well the sensation it cause–as did the tv version. I have often thought that most of the complaints had more to do with racism–a black author having a mega-bestelling book in 1976 that then became a tv phenomenon. Of course, it is an oral tradition–not till after the Civil War could any slave learn to read or write–it was also against the law to teach them. When white anthropologists like Mead/Bateson documented things from oral traditions they were applauded.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Oct 13, 2021 @ 07:38:15
That’s a really interesting comment, thank you! I think an element of racism and I expect some sour grapes as it was such a huge bestseller at the time, and in print continuously since, I think. And the point is even made in the book about some slaves who are able to read and write but must hide it – and Kizzy’s sale hinges on that, too.
LikeLiked by 1 person
hopewellslibraryoflife
Oct 13, 2021 @ 12:28:44
Some did learn on their own in secret (think of kids who have just “got it” as little ones) and others were secretly taught. Abolitionists did what they could on that front.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Grab the Lapels
Oct 12, 2021 @ 15:04:06
People were clinging to novels like Uncle Tom’s Cabin to reassure themselves that while slavery was bad, there was some slave owners who were loved by their slaves. I hadn’t thought of Haley’s book being in conversation with Uncle Tom’s Cabin because they came out so far apart, but it’s true, they do talk to teach other, in a way.
I also enjoyed the African setting the best, especially all the anthropological information about the society in which Kunta grew up. Even though his people did things that made me surprised, I never felt like an outsider judging the society. Haley doesn’t allow space for that in his writing because he also clearly portrays Kunta’s excitement for being grown, for loving his mother and yet wanting to leave her and become a man, etc.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Oct 13, 2021 @ 07:40:34
Two excellent points there, thank you. There was always the worry in the African section about when he was going to be captured but yes, I loved the family relationships and the way we were drawn in, especially, I think, because of the assumption we would know or look up terms rather than having everything explained to us.
LikeLiked by 1 person
heavenali
Oct 12, 2021 @ 16:27:33
I think I might have seen at least bits of the TV series but it can’t have been in 1976 (I was 8).
I ‘m delighted you got so much from reading this with your group. It sounds like an incredible reading experience and I can see why you use the word heartbreaking. I wonder if I could cope with such a long book of such devastating, traumatic stories.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Oct 13, 2021 @ 07:42:24
Given that I could manage it, I’m sure you could. Nothing was gratuitous and there was always story in there, even in the grinding horror of the boat journey, and flashes of hope in him understanding the non-Muslims he was meeting for the first time could be decent people, or seeing different peoples of Africa he’d only heard of before, knowledge he carries onwards into his American life. And there’s hope in just the story being told and encouraging others to know truth and to research their own families.
LikeLike
imogenglad
Oct 12, 2021 @ 20:34:44
I remember my parents talking about the TV adaptation, but again I would have been too young as I was 2 in 1976! The book was one I’d see in the school library in the 80s too, it was totally ubiquitous. Still, I never read it! Perhaps I now should!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Oct 13, 2021 @ 07:43:11
I can remember seeing it around here and there in the 80s, too. I do recommend it; it’s both important and a good read (apart from the too-much-chickens bit maybe).
LikeLiked by 1 person
WordsAndPeace
Oct 12, 2021 @ 21:26:01
Nice! I enjoyed it a lot when I read it many years ago.
Here is my post for the #1976Club: https://wordsandpeace.com/2021/10/12/my-top-10-books-for-the-1976-club/
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Oct 13, 2021 @ 07:43:52
Ah, brilliant, thank you – I’ve picked that post up in my Feedly reader too so will pop to it later today. It is an amazing book, isn’t it, and I’m so glad I’ve read it.
LikeLike
Brona's Books
Oct 12, 2021 @ 22:18:01
Congratulations on reading such a hefty tome!
As I said on Bill’s post, my main recollection of this is being sent to bed as a 10 yr old when my parents sat down to watch the original tv series back in 1977 or ’78 and seeing the book sitting on dadās bookshelf, with a half naked black man on the cover. At the time I thought I was banned from watching it because it was a āsexyā story.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Liz Dexter
Oct 13, 2021 @ 07:45:00
Thank you, and I did smile when I saw that comment on Bill’s post, too! Just shows that we should explain to children why they’re not being allowed to watch or read certain things, maybe! My copy has quite a restrained cover with just the title but the O’s are a broken chain.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Wendy
Oct 12, 2021 @ 22:52:02
I was 13 years old when the TV series Roots started. It was something never seen before on American TV and it was an eye-opener. Like so much about our history, we were never told about this part of our history. It was really revolutionary for that time. I would love to read the book! I’ll add it to my mountain of TBRs…
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Oct 13, 2021 @ 07:46:03
Ah, that’s interesting, thank you. It’s so fascinating thinking of the different contexts in which we’ve encountered this book; I did come from a position of knowing a certain amount and being prepared for it. It is a good read, I do recommend it, though a whopper in size!
LikeLike
Davida Chazan
Oct 13, 2021 @ 08:01:54
Well, in 1976 I was 18-19, so I remember the book coming out, but I never read it. I did watch the TV series, which was really good, if I recall correctly.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Oct 13, 2021 @ 08:34:50
It’s interesting, the book/TV series split. I don’t think I could face watching it, to be honest. Do you recall knowing about any of the issues/history before seeing it?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Davida Chazan
Oct 13, 2021 @ 10:42:12
Oh, yes… I did. See… I come from a very liberal town, and teaching us about slavery properly was a big issue for our schools. We integrated our elementary schools when I was in 5th grade, and I studied with a racially diverse group of students through High School. Plus, my town was the FIRST one in the US to start giving reparations to African American residents. Look it up – Evanston, Illinois. (Made me feel very proud!)
LikeLiked by 1 person
Davida Chazan
Oct 13, 2021 @ 10:43:38
By the way… Haley being black himself really was quite innovative to publish this book. I should read it… hm…
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Oct 13, 2021 @ 10:49:38
Oh, what a wonderful thing to read about. And it’s fascinating how many perspectives people have come to the book/film from, thank you for sharing yours.
LikeLiked by 1 person
#1976Club Alex Haleyās Roots (1976) – Buried In Print
Oct 13, 2021 @ 16:03:03
swosei12blog
Oct 13, 2021 @ 17:04:11
I was not born at the time, but I remember BET (Black Entertainment Television, a cable network) used to show the mini series almost every year around the holidays. In addition, the network would show Roots: The Next Generations (based on the last few chapters of Roots) and Queen (about Alex’s grandmother – not sure paternal or maternal). If memory serves me correctly, I think he died before he finished writing Queen.
For Roots, the only part that I “enjoyed” were the recounts of Kunta when he was in Africa, but the rest of the book/miniseries was a bit traumatic for me. I remember my mother, who grew up in the South during Jim Crow, proclaiming that we would not allowed to watch the miniseries in HER house. After rewatching the entire miniseries as an adult, I understand her point. I did attempt to read the novel in college, but I think that I made it halfway through the book. I enjoyed Roots: The Next Generation because it was a bit more positive and less traumatic.
I was a bit disappointed when I learned that Hailey may have plagiarized a large chunk of Roots.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Oct 13, 2021 @ 17:19:06
Thank you for your detailed comment and I’m sorry if I’ve stirred up memories of the traumatic aspect of engaging with the book and series. I wouldn’t say I enjoyed it from my more distant position, either, but it was certainly a compelling read and yes, the parts in Africa and also I think the parts where Tom helped found the new town after Emancipation and got one over on the White folk who tried to stop him setting up a shop were also really interesting, as that was an aspect I hadn’t read about before. I haven’t got “The Next Generation” (yet) but I have acquired a copy of “Queen” which is about his maternal ancestors (I think going further back than his grandmother) and indeed written with someone else.
The area about plagiarism and poor research is a difficult one. As a commenter notes above, how much of this was expectations of an oral tradition due to people not being permitted to keep written records? I think he did his best to pull together sources to give a visceral account of the humanity of slavery, from Black people’s point of view, which hadn’t been done before or to such a popular degree. So I will forgive him, I think, given the huge effect he had in America and, apparently, here in the UK, too.
LikeLiked by 1 person
tracybham
Oct 13, 2021 @ 17:04:15
I was 28 when this was on TV. I remember watching it but my first marriage was falling apart at the time so maybe I watched it in reruns with my current husband. I lived in California then (still do) and had been raised in Alabama but in a family that supported integration. I remember being very impressed with the series and with LeVar Burton as Kunta Kinte.
I have never read the book and am intimidated by nearly 900 pages but I can see it would be worthwhile. I enjoyed your review and the one at Buried in Print.
LikeLike
Liz Dexter
Oct 14, 2021 @ 05:24:50
Thank you for popping over to comment! And it’s good to hear from people whose families supported integration, and must have been interesting living in Alabama (hence your username, I imagine; I’m in the “other” Birmingham and have visited the AL one!). It does sound like an excellent series, too. The book doesn’t feel like that many pages. We did read it 30 chapters per week but the chapters are quite short and it certainly didn’t take all week to read each section. I do recommend it!
LikeLike
deborahbrooks14
Oct 13, 2021 @ 17:42:57
I know I have seen the movie but not sure I ever read it. Thanks for the idea!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Oct 14, 2021 @ 05:26:18
It’s very well worth reading, and it’s written pretty accessibly, also with short chapters, so it’s quite a quick read in that sense, though of course not an easy one.
LikeLike
buriedinprint
Oct 13, 2021 @ 18:01:07
You and Bill were such great reading companions during this read. And I love to see all the varied observations and comments about how/whether the mini-series or the book(s) registered with different people (readers or viewers). Not to take away from the validity of your point about it being overwhelmingly heart-breaking, but I also think there’s a lot of resilience and power in the family’s survival, despite everything. I’m looking forward to reading/viewing more, although unlikely to finish anything else during this week (my video requests took longer than expected, and the sequel arrived before the original, wouldn’t you know).
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Oct 14, 2021 @ 05:27:42
You’re right, there is a lot of hope and resilience in there, too, and that’s what makes it a good and valuable read. It was an excellent experience doing a readalong and I’m so glad you prompted me into it!
LikeLike
Michelle @ Running with Attitude
Oct 13, 2021 @ 18:41:52
I was 11 when Roots premiered on TV. I remember it being difficult to watch but so important to see the story told to a national audience. Truly an important book then, and now. I have always wanted to read it, but have never been sure I could let myself go there – as you said, too brutal, too hard.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Liz Dexter
Oct 14, 2021 @ 05:30:32
Goodness, that was quite young to watch it. But yes, so important of course, and I was fascinated to read about the effect it had here in the UK, too. If you’ve seen it you can probably manage the read, however I’m saying that obviously from a position of coming at it from a different background and nation (although the nation bit doesn’t really help as the UK was just as complicit and many of the early characters are UK settlers). I would say none of the violence is gratuitous but it is a hard read at times. I’d be interested in what you think if you do read it.
LikeLiked by 1 person
gertloveday
Oct 16, 2021 @ 02:05:47
A fabulous review and a great achievement. I read around the edges of slavery. Jeff Sparrow’s book No Way but This : In Search of Paul Robeson is inspiring.
LikeLike
Liz Dexter
Oct 16, 2021 @ 14:38:47
Thank you. It was a surprisingly quick read for its size! That does sound like an interesting book – thank you for the rec!
LikeLiked by 1 person
NottsReader
Oct 19, 2021 @ 04:45:55
Intresting thing about the TV show, when it was shown on tv in America, they did it over consecertive, nights not because they thought it was a going to be a hit, quit the obvious it was done so if it flopped then the channel would get it done in one week.
in addition all the slave owners were played by actors who pewviously played by actors who, had played popular dads on tv, to affect how the viewers saw them. In addition Kunta Kinte as a young man was played by LeVar Burton of star trek the next generation fame.
LikeLike
Liz Dexter
Oct 19, 2021 @ 07:31:12
Welcome to my blog and thank you for your comment. I knew that about the scheduling, also if it didn’t get good viewing rates it was scheduled anyway so would be able to finish. I didn’t know that about the actors playing the slave owners, but I did know about Burton, thanks to Buried In Print’s review!
LikeLiked by 1 person
1976 Club: Review Round-Up – Stuck in a Book
Oct 19, 2021 @ 15:44:25
Susan
Oct 20, 2021 @ 13:27:21
Yes I recall watching the original series and was young and blown out of the water by it. It made a big impact. And was huge for its time.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Oct 20, 2021 @ 13:50:47
Thank you for your comment. Did you ever read the book as well? I can’t imagine the effect the TV series had on people.
LikeLike
Susan
Oct 21, 2021 @ 16:53:25
No I never read Haley’s Book. It’s great your reading group took it on. Very interesting your review and observations. When we watched the TV series, I was about 11 years old in 1977. I guess there were 8 episodes that ran on consecutive nights … it was hard to turn away from.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Oct 22, 2021 @ 07:50:53
Yes, they did that to ensure it would still run to the end even if it had poor ratings, apparently. That was young to watch it – it must have made a big impression!
LikeLike
Simon T
Oct 21, 2021 @ 16:13:22
Gosh, you certainly win the prize for the longest book read for the club – and now you’ve got an even longer one?! Thanks for adding it to the club!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Oct 22, 2021 @ 07:51:37
And three of us read it so I bet we got the highest combined page count! Anyway I am SO glad I got to read it, so thank you. Might well go more svelte for the next Week!
LikeLike
Book review – Toufah Jallow with Kim Pittaway – “Toufah” | Adventures in reading, running and working from home
Oct 28, 2021 @ 16:21:00
State of the TBR – November 2021 | Adventures in reading, running and working from home
Nov 01, 2021 @ 09:00:22
Nonfiction November Week 2: Book Pairing | Adventures in reading, running and working from home
Nov 08, 2021 @ 09:00:20
Nonfiction November Week 3: Be the Expert / Ask the Expert | Adventures in reading, running and working from home
Nov 15, 2021 @ 08:01:51
ShiraDest
Dec 19, 2021 @ 02:14:25
“he just places the terms there and, presumably, expects you to know what they meant or look them up (some I did, some I did, if you see what I mean). ”
Excellent to know: I’ve gotten lots of push-back from readers of my work, here on the blog and in my book Stayed… to define and “unpack” more, when I had expected that readers would look up a few things. Perhaps nowadays, readers have less tolerance for researching?
Shira
LikeLike
Liz Dexter
Dec 19, 2021 @ 07:59:58
That is interesting, there is a fine line between using very specialised terms and explaining nothing and explaining everything and putting off people who know stuff or are happy to look it up rather than be pulled out of the story with explanations. I’m not sure whether readers have less tolerance for researching nowadays. I feel like Indian and African books I read have less explanation (though maybe a glossary at the back) than they used to, but I might be seeing that out of nothing. I am a bit surprised Haley did this, actually, given his passion for including everything he found in his research in his book!
LikeLiked by 1 person
ShiraDest
Dec 19, 2021 @ 17:27:22
Hmm, I wonder how much was edited out by others? I personally like the idea of an index/appendix, but can you do that with a novel?
(I have seen epilogues that looked like responses to readers, but in 3rd or later runs, rather than initial printings of novels…)
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Dec 19, 2021 @ 17:42:20
Not an index or appendix but a glossary, just a list of terms and translations/explanations. I’ve seen that in a few books, although of course I can’t find an example right now. I don’t imagine Roots was edited to remove all the explanations of things, although obviously I don’t know for sure. The author went to Africa to learn about traditional ways of life and did a lot of research.
LikeLiked by 1 person
ShiraDest
Dec 19, 2021 @ 17:49:41
Glossary makes sense.
I didn’t mean to imply an editing out, but only that I’m sure he’d have liked to have put in more explanation. I’ve had that experience in my own pubs, where editors tell me to move explanations to the appendix. I’d love to see more of his refs from Africa! I can still remember the scene in Roots where he finally finds the link (ok, James Earl Jones, in the scene!).
š
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Dec 19, 2021 @ 17:56:36
I’ve not seen the TV series, I’ve only read the book, but that must have been something special in the series. I think an appendix can be perfectly acceptable and a good choice.
LikeLiked by 1 person
ShiraDest
Dec 19, 2021 @ 20:35:43
Ah!
LikeLike
Book review – Thomas Harding – “White Debt” | Adventures in reading, running and working from home
Feb 04, 2022 @ 09:47:15
Book review – Doris Pilkington / Nugi Garimara – “Follow the Rabbit-Proof Fence” | Adventures in reading, running and working from home
Nov 04, 2022 @ 08:00:52
Book review - Alex Haley and David Stevens - "Queen"
Jul 08, 2023 @ 08:02:09
Book review - Yaa Gyasi - "Homegoing"
Jul 16, 2023 @ 17:24:31
Book review - James Baldwin - "Go Tell it on the Mountain"
Jul 24, 2023 @ 08:00:45