A book from NetGalley which I spotted and downloaded in January, also published in January. I was intrigued by its division into chapters based on types of fabric, and by the fact it was a “people’s history” and I’m very glad I downloaded it.
Sofi Thanhauser – “Worn: A People’s History of Clothing”
(12 January 2022 – NetGalley)
Unerringly, cloth tells the story of the rise and fall of our societies and our cultures. And, perhaps, it does so more accurately than any words can.
Using main section headings of Linen, Cotton, Silk, Synthetics and Wool allows the author to take a historical view of the emergence of different fabrics and technologies (both to make them and to make things out of them); but she also takes a view based around gender, race and class, which makes it more interesting and valuable. She constantly points out how developments in markets and technology end up with women or Global Majority People being exploited and driven into poverty and despair while the administration and the White men end up with the profit and little of the work. Interestingly, this is sometimes cyclical – the downtrodden seamstresses in the 19th century have more in common with garment factory workers now than with the unionised specialists of the 1950s, for example.
After charting her own interest in fashion and clothing, via learning how to sew herself and realising – as many don’t – that someone has to create and make our clothes, Thanhauser weaves (sorry) a fascinating history of clothing types and their construction and materials, moving from individual crops and making clothes for the household to the international garment trade today. She also weaves in the ideological movements contemporary with these developments and changes, from the construction of race to the assumption that women didn’t need to earn as much because there was always a man to bankroll them (in slavery times, it was cheaper to have teams of women making clothing for slaves than it was to have slaves make them!). She has a worldwide focus, bringing in people and practices from America to Russia via England and Asia, and visits a lot of locations, talking to workers and, more often, business owners. Health and safety and care for workers, and the accompanying attempts to unionise, are highlighted throughout the book, and modern “feminism” is critiqued as being about a few exceptional entrepreneurs rather than the still horrendous lot of women in the clothing industries.
The last section, on wool, takes a different approach, and looks at the revival of crafts, including within Indigenous American communities, talking to a variety of practitioners including a transperson who is reviving a tradition whereby they will form a backbone in their community for telling stories and keeping crafts going.
The severe and prolonged violence that has annihilated the world’s weaving traditions cannot be seen in isolation from the destruction of agricultural systems, sovereignties, communal values, and identities. Neither should the resurrection of weaving traditions be seen in isolation: cloth cannot be viewed separately from the entire material and social basis from which it springs.
It’s a book that finds a lot of problems and doesn’t have a huge lot of solutions, apart from trying to keep things local, recycle, buy second-hand, mend clothing and maintain traditions. But that’s a start, in this deep and wide-ranging book that has an awful lot to recommend it, interrogating intersectional inequities while engaging in historical work.
Thank you to Allen Lane for making this book available via NetGalley in return for an honest review. “Worn” is published on 27 January.
Jan 22, 2022 @ 17:18:41
Really interesting, thank you for bringing it to my attention. I’m now going to share š
LikeLiked by 1 person
Jan 22, 2022 @ 17:30:39
I’m so glad I picked up on it and read it. There was a review in one of the Saturday papers today so I hope it gets the coverage it deserves – thank you for sharing!
LikeLike
Jan 22, 2022 @ 17:56:47
This sounds great. I’m not good at spotting non-fiction that appeals so thanks for flagging it up
LikeLiked by 1 person
Jan 22, 2022 @ 18:11:31
Highly recommended. I rely on reviews in the paper and magazine I read and then blogs and NetGalley: I’m sure I miss a lot!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Jan 22, 2022 @ 18:07:46
Oh wow this book looks right up my alley!!!! Thank you for sharing with us – just added it to my TBR.
LikeLike
Jan 22, 2022 @ 18:12:11
Welcome to my blog, and that’s great, seems to be appealing to quite a few people so I’m glad I was able to highlight it!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Jan 22, 2022 @ 19:45:28
Sounds really interesting, Liz. I know from what I’ve heard from my Offspring about the sweat shops which still exist in our country and in this day and age, and it is definitely women and often women from non-white cultures who are being exploited. And it’s hard to know how to tackle things because of white male capitalism, so I get why she can name the problems but not come up with solutions. Even as a consumer it’s hard to know how to proceed – you buy a garment in Primark or one in Gap and most likely the person who made it is getting paid the same in both cases, but the profit margin for the latter company is massive. I certainly think if we got out of the mindset of fast fashion that would help but the whole system needs a complete overhaul, really.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Jan 24, 2022 @ 11:17:42
Yes, that’s one thing that will help, but it’s hard, and it’s hard to find reputable, ethical companies as they all make statements but then do they follow through?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Jan 23, 2022 @ 14:00:09
Sounds fascinating, and I like the idea of her classification into different fabrics; it’s sad that the idea that a woman needn’t earn as much still continues in many places/sectors.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Jan 24, 2022 @ 11:18:12
Yes, the gender pay gap is still alive and kicking and “women’s work” seen as less valuable.
LikeLike
Jan 24, 2022 @ 20:03:01
Sounds like a worthwhile read indeed. And I get what you’re saying, that there are more problems than solutions, but those solutions they’ve offered are game-changers to be sure. I think of all the people who ask “where do you find those books” and it’s simply that one goes looking for them. Not in the drugstore while you’re standing in line, picking up a paperback in the rack alongside on a whim. It takes a different approach to find a different kind of book. But they’re there. Not all that different in other sectors, even though of course there are some aspects of the industries that we can’t affect directly at the consumer-level. Did you find it inspiring overall?
LikeLiked by 2 people
Jan 24, 2022 @ 20:49:32
I found it very interesting and I really liked the attention paid to intersections of class, gender and race. Not sure about inspiring, apart from the stuff about modern revivals of weaving – I’m very frugal anyway and tend to avoid fast fashion and wear clothing until it falls apart, at which point I donate it to a charity for rags or make it into cleaning rags! I mend things, too. Very unfashionable in both senses of the word!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Jan 25, 2022 @ 16:27:45
This sounds really interesting Liz. Incidentally, BBC R4 are broadcasting it on the the morning book slot this week – available to catch up on BBC Sounds.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Jan 26, 2022 @ 09:55:53
Oh, that is good news. I saw a review in the New Statesman or the Guardian but haven’t seen a lot of buzz about it and it’s very good.
LikeLike
Jan 26, 2022 @ 02:47:07
Thank you for highlighting such a unique (and timely) topic and book. I am passing this title along to my friend who is a textile artist (or perhaps will gift her the book instead!).
LikeLiked by 1 person
Jan 26, 2022 @ 09:56:28
Oh, I expect she’ll find it very interesting, and will definitely enjoy the later chapters on the revival of weaving arts, etc.
LikeLiked by 1 person
State of the TBR – February 2022 | Adventures in reading, running and working from home
Feb 01, 2022 @ 09:50:23