I wasn’t going to take part in Stuckinabook and Kaggsy’s Bookish Ramblings’ 1936 Club (they do a year-themed read twice a year) as I didn’t have anything from 1936 on my TBR and I’ve been being really careful to only do book challenges from my TBR. But then I realised that this book, which has been republished this year in the list Bernadine Evaristo has curated for Penguin, “Black Britain Writing Back“, I had to go and buy a copy and read it. And I’m very glad I did!
Simon’s page here and Kaggsy’s here explain everything and hold the lists of what everyone has read this week.
C.L.R. James – “Minty Alley”
(2 April 2021)
This was the first novel by a Black Caribbean author to be published in England, and as Bernadine Evaristo points out in her introduction, he came as a lone figure in the 1930s, way before the Windrush generation and their chroniclers, pointing out the debt Sam Selvon owes to this work of social realism (I re-read and reviewed his “The Lonely Londoners” recently (in fact for the last Year Club, the 1956 Club!). It’s the fairly simple story of middle-class Haynes, 20 years old, his mother dead, who needs to move into a working-class boarding house for complicated financial reasons. In Minty Alley he grows a spine and allows himself to get involved with the various characters who live there, all seen in comparison to him, brighter and more colourful.
The sea of life was beating at the walls which enclosed him. Nervously and full of self-distrust, he had been fighting against taking the plunge, but he would have to sometime. (p. 6)
While a lot of the details of living in 1930s Trinidad are of course specific to the time and place, there is a real universality about this book, too. It reminded me of works by R.K. Narayan set in India, and also Patrick Hamilton’s “The Slaves of Solitude” set in a wartime London boarding house – the petty quarrels, the issues of food, poverty and its genteel hiding, the problem of rubbing along with others. Haynes is fortunate in that he has the mother figure of his old servant Ella, always keeping an eye on him, even if it’s from a distance. The town of Port of Spain is almost another character, providing a web of gossip and almost a chorus. Nothing can happen in one street without the whole town knowing.
Haynes tries to stay out of the arguments and issues among his landlady, her niece, the irrepressible Maisie, her wandering-eyed and -handed common-law husband, her faithful servant Philomen and the other residents, but soon finds himself getting drawn in, in a number of different ways. He’s seen as a gentleman and thus is able to have a positive and/or calming influence on the rest of the house, even Maisie, although she gets one up on him too on occasion.
There was scarcely an occasion Haynes could remember in which Maisie either through inadvertence or malice, or both, did not with infallible instinct say or do the thing most calculated to ignite Mrs Rouse. (p. 168)
Of course events can’t just jog along and must come to a head, with a hilarious scene which is once again both specific and universal. It’s the kind of book you can’t stop reading, and I do wish James had written more than just this one novel (he wrote a lot of books of biography and politics, but no other novels).
So an engaging, charming and funny book with a sharp edge of racism (especially against the Chinese origin population) and colourism (before colourism was talked about, according to the introduction but something I’d also noticed). I really recommend it as a lovely read in itself, but with historical and sociological interest, too.
Other books from 1936 I’ve read and reviewed here (I know I’ve read others, e.g. the Agatha Christies, George Orwell’s “Keep the Aspidistra Flying, but before the book blog!) …
Daphne du Maurier – Jamaica Inn
Winifred Holtby – South Riding
Margaret Mitchell – Gone with the Wind
Angela Thirkell – August Folly
Francis Brett Young – Far Forest
anewlookthrougholdeyes
Apr 16, 2021 @ 09:04:57
Excellent review. I hadn’t realised he had written a novel but was recently reminded of him when I came across my autographed copy of Paul Robeson Here I Stand. So easy to forget how many radical black writers there were. I’ve only just discovered the 1936 book club and as it is the year of my birth shall try and listen to as much as is available on audio. Big thank you for writing about this novel.
LikeLike
Liz Dexter
Apr 16, 2021 @ 10:09:59
You would really enjoy this one and it is available on Audible. It’s fortuitous they picked that year this time! I would have liked to have re-read the Orwell but didn’t have time in the week – but the lists Simon and Karen put together will give you lots of ideas!
LikeLiked by 1 person
anewlookthrougholdeyes
Apr 21, 2021 @ 09:00:23
You are right Liz! I did love Minty Alley. The narrator on audible, Ben Onukwe, perfectly captured all the humour, characterisation, humanity and tragedy of this wonderful book. I had read Beyond the Boundery and was bowled over by the very different Minty Alley! Sorry, couldn’t resist that! The perfect description of class, colour and the struggle to maintain a dignified life while living in poverty was written without comment and spoke for itself.
LikeLiked by 2 people
Liz Dexter
Apr 21, 2021 @ 09:02:24
Oh I’m so glad, and thank you for including a note on the narrator which I have passed on to Matthew. It was an excellent book, wasn’t it – definitely showing not telling.
LikeLiked by 2 people
anewlookthrougholdeyes
Apr 21, 2021 @ 10:18:22
The narrator makes all the difference. This is a novel I believe came across particularly effectively when read aloud. Hope Matthew likes it. I’m going to look out for more by the same reader.
LikeLiked by 2 people
anewlookthrougholdeyes
Apr 16, 2021 @ 10:17:06
Good timing! I’ve already downloaded it! Thanks.
LikeLiked by 1 person
JacquiWine
Apr 16, 2021 @ 13:07:37
Interesting you should mention the Sam Selvon because it immediately came to mind! And your reference to the world of Patrick Hamilton also piques my interest, a wonderful writer of the boarding house milieu. I think I’ll be adding this to my wishlist pdq.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Apr 16, 2021 @ 13:27:14
Yes, I mean Selvon is writing about the younger members of this society and their sons and daughters coming to the UK, but also obviously came himself that bit later. I think you would like this, and it supports Bernadine Evaristo’s fabulous list as well of course!
LikeLike
hopewellslibraryoflife
Apr 16, 2021 @ 14:05:15
What an interesting and important book–since it was a “first.”
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Apr 16, 2021 @ 14:21:45
Yes – and also a really good read!
LikeLike
kaggsysbookishramblings
Apr 16, 2021 @ 18:15:01
Great review Liz, and what a wonderful find from 1936 – just proves what a variety there was in that year, and this sounds great. So glad you spotted the date and were able to join in! 😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Apr 16, 2021 @ 18:27:03
It was brilliant, just my type of book and I was so pleased to get hold of it. Now I don’t even know how I discovered it matched the date! Oh well – a good result!
LikeLike
heavenali
Apr 16, 2021 @ 18:39:06
Excellent review. I saved it until I had finished mine. We clearly both loved it. I notice you reference The Lonely Londoners and I am reminded again that I really want to read it.
LikeLike
Liz Dexter
Apr 17, 2021 @ 05:44:14
I’ll lend you my rather battered copy, you will love it as we loved this one!
LikeLike
Simon T
Apr 16, 2021 @ 19:48:44
Oo this sounds great, and I love the sound of that Evaristo series. Thanks for joining in – glad you were swayed 😀
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Apr 17, 2021 @ 05:45:25
The series is really interesting, Ali has read and reviewed another one on the list. And yes this was great and I’m glad I was swayed!
LikeLike
#1936Club – links round-up – Stuck in a Book
Apr 16, 2021 @ 19:55:20
Grab the Lapels
Apr 16, 2021 @ 21:10:32
I forgot Jamaica Inn came out in 1936. I loved and feared that book. I haven’t read Gone with the Wind, but I do recall reading in Flannery O’Connor’s bio that she was so mad when she said she was a writer and other folks would tell her to be like that Gone with the Wind author simply because both women were in Georgia.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Apr 17, 2021 @ 05:46:24
That must have been infuriating! Not sure I loved Jamaica Inn but certainly couldn’t put it down.
LikeLiked by 1 person
buriedinprint
Apr 16, 2021 @ 22:13:29
What a perfect excuse to broaden your reading choices. Ms Evaristo would approve (as do many readers/commenters, I’m sure!).
LikeLike
Liz Dexter
Apr 17, 2021 @ 05:52:58
I’m not sure it was broadening my reading choices as such – I’ve always read quite a lot of books by Global Majority Peoples authors set in the Caribbean, India and elsewhere as well as in the UK and America, fiction and nonfiction (cf the fact I mention Selvdon and Narayan in the review). This was just the sort of book I like and have done for years, and I’m so glad this was given a chance to be republished and several of the nonfiction books I’ve picked up recently an opportunity to be published at all.
LikeLike
buriedinprint
Apr 20, 2021 @ 14:12:07
Oh, actually what I meant was that the event was the perfect excuse for you to add to your shelves and give yourself another choice to read for 1936…I can see how it could have come across the other way, but I have been following you for quite awhile, long enough to know that you do make an effort to read diversely. 🙂
LikeLiked by 2 people
Liz Dexter
Apr 20, 2021 @ 14:41:24
Ah, thank you for explaining, and I’m glad it was meant that way around. I do sometimes get people commenting on the perceived sudden diversity in my book buying or reading so I am a bit sensitive to that. Anyway the main thing is this was an excellent read!
LikeLiked by 2 people
Jane
Apr 17, 2021 @ 15:42:17
I hadn’t seen the Black Britain Writing Back list so thank you Liz, this sounds excellent but I must look at the whole list too.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Apr 18, 2021 @ 11:16:54
It’s a really varied and interesting list and I will certainly be picking up at least a couple more of them!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Deborah Brooks
Apr 18, 2021 @ 18:00:13
I just finished “perfect marriage” which I loved and currently in audible version of “invisible girl” which I am not really into
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Apr 19, 2021 @ 08:43:35
Who are those by? Are you going to finish the second one: is it the book or the narrator that’s not engaging you?
LikeLike
Book review – V. S. Naipaul – “Miguel Street” | Adventures in reading, running and working from home
Nov 30, 2021 @ 18:18:11
Book stats and best books of 2021 | Adventures in reading, running and working from home
Dec 31, 2021 @ 19:25:50