I was offered a copy of this by the publisher, and the email said it was for fans of Black Cake, The Girl with the Louding Voice and My Name is Leon: I can understand this, as it’s a lovely coming of age story about a resilient teenager carving her own way in the world like all of those, but with its own differences.

Ishi Robinson – “Sweetness in the Skin”

(24 November 2023, NetGalley)

I feel the tiniest little stab somewhere in my side at the idea that my poverty is an adventure for her, but eventually I smile back. Maybe, I think, it won’t be so bad. Maybe she’ll see me for who I really am and I can stop pretentding. Maybe this will be a good thing.

Pumkin lives in a small house half way between the near-slums and the good areas in Kingston, Jamaica, able to go to a good school because her Aunt Sophie pays her school fees, but feeling like she has to hide that she lives in a tiny house with her grandmother, her mother who wants little to do with her and resents Sophie and her sophisticated aunt who’s also teaching her ways of hiding who you are, working at the French embassy and dreaming of moving to France.

When Sophie gets her dream, she promised to send for Pumkin, but Pumkin’s mum turns on her and refuses to let her take the exam she needs, no good at standing up for her when things go wrong at school. But Pumkin has a secret weapon: two, actually – her ability to make friends and her ability to bake. Surrounded by found family and adding people to it, notably a rather scary teacher at a French language school she needs to attend to get her exam, she bakes her way to having the requisite savings and gathers folk around her who can help her when the going gets tough. Will she make it to France, and does she need to?

I was worried this was going to be a simple bootstraps out of shameful poverty story – but it’s not, she sees the value in her roots, laughs at a posh friend who can’t cope visiting her and is not ashamed of herself – or that she’d find a White boyfriend to help her – again, no, just a variety of different Jamaican friends, including older women and a lovely guy who’s just a lovely guy and nothing else. There’s an underlying strong message about colourism and class, Pumkin’s mum having darker skin than Aunt Sophie and thus being less favoured, and class distinctions being harsh.

With some borderline distressing scenes (nothing as bad as in “The Girl with the Louding Voice”) this was on the whole a lovely, positive read which was also realistic in the hard work Pumkin put in and the sometimes strained relationships with her friends and family.

Thank you to Penguin Random House for offering me a copy of this book to read via NetGalley in return for an honest review. “Sweetness in the Skin” was published on 11 April 2024.