It’s that time of the month again – we’re recapping our reading and discussion of “Bruno’s Dream” and looking ahead to “A Fairly Honourable Defeat”
A brisk and interesting discussion is going on on my review of “Bruno’s Dream” (do join in even if you’ve read it after October 2018!). We agreed that Nigel is odd (is he an incarnation of God or a weird, uncanny hippie?) and the book is full of rather unsavoury people and power relationships. Yet it’s a good read, very atmospheric, and not as gloomy and full of death as I thought when I first read it as a teenager (I remain endlessly fascinated by the process of re-reading and our changing attitudes to familiar books.
Also do post there in the comments if you’ve reviewed the book on your own website, blog or Goodreads page. So far, Jo has posted another of her excellent reviews on Goodreads as well as joining in the discussion on the review page. I’ll add more links as you let me know about them.
Now for some reader-submitted covers. Peter Rivenberg and Jo Smith have both sent me images of the Viking US first edition, not a cobweb in sight! What is that actually an image of?
That image from Peter, and here’s the rather lovely author pic, in Jo’s version:
Peter also has the most deliciously horrendous and inappropriate copy of the Dell paperback.
Really? And who is this: Danby and Adelaide or Miles and Lisa??? And the back cover blurb …
Really, really? Keep them coming: I love these!
“A Fairly Honourable Defeat”
This is one of my favourite of IM’s novels, and features, new readers will be glad to know, the character Tallis who I keep going on about in my reviews.
I have the customary three copies: my Chatto & Windus first edition, my 1980s Penguin reprint, and my new red-spined Vintage Classic with introduction.
More cover art from the first, as the disturbing image wraps right around the back!
Lovely! Competition to work out who all these people are coming soon!
So the blurb is quite straightforward in the first:
I love this: it explains who the main characters are, raises the idea of Julius and Tallis fighting over Morgan and discusses the final defeat. We go a bit more minimalist with the other two. Here’s the Penguin:
And well, that gives it away a bit, right? And the Vintage is getting into the whole Shakespearean thing but I’m not sure about that first paragraph. We’ll see.
Are you going to be reading or re-reading “A Fairly Honourable Defeat” along with me? Are you catching up with the others or have you given up)? What’s your favourite so far? Your least favourite?
You will find a page listing all of these blog posts here, updated as I go along.
Jo
Oct 31, 2018 @ 23:04:00
I’m so bemused by that Dell cover and blurb, clearly the publisher was trying for a wider – or entirely different audience! I’ll be joining in for my first read of A Fairly Honorable Defeat and my library actually had a 1970 Viking edition so if you don’t have that cover image Liz, let me know.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Nov 01, 2018 @ 06:26:05
I know – and ended up with a few disappointed or bemused readers, I’d imagine! I don’t have any of the Vikings, so please do send on when you have a moment. Can it beat the UK one for oddness?
LikeLike
integratedexpat
Nov 26, 2018 @ 22:29:13
What an odd coincidence! I happened to decide to go back to read some blog posts I’d missed, starting on 1 November so started with this one on here. Earlier on, however, I was translating something about plant reproduction and hermaphrodites and on the Dutch Wikipedia I had seen a photo of a statue of Hermaphroditis, son of Hermes and Aphrodite. It’s rather reminiscent of your Chatto & Windus cover. Best not to look at the English illustration of hermaphroditism on Wikipedia, though, if you’re not into full frontal nudity of a rather medical nature!
LikeLike
Liz Dexter
Nov 27, 2018 @ 07:47:06
How interesting! Have you read many Iris Murdoch books yourself? Lots of gender swapping going on, or at least girls being treated like boys …
LikeLike
integratedexpat
Nov 27, 2018 @ 11:05:12
I’m not sure I’ve read any at all, but I have Under the Net champing at the bit. My TBR bookshelf is somewhat larger than yours, however. I do happen to be reading a book with the main character who is transgender: When We Speak About Nothing, by Olumide Popoola. There is remarkably little about being transgender, as it’s not about the process and the family at home is accepting. A long-absent father in Nigeria is another matter altogether. In fact, all the themes addressed are pretty low key, simmering rather than boiling over. Even a pivotal event involving riots is not given much weight in the writing. It’s the sort of thing that could be taken and made into a really exciting film by a good screenwriter, or it would make a good jumping point for all sorts of topical discussions with teenagers, but the book itself is rather underwhelming.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Liz Dexter
Nov 27, 2018 @ 11:18:44
Oh that does sound like a missed opportunity. Hope you get to read Under the Net soon! Do pop by the first post in this series and add your thoughts when you have done.
LikeLike